Mystery Vintage Ugly Christmas Sweater
How It Works
Let us surprise you.
Pick your style (pullover, cardigan, or vest) and your size (S–XL), and we'll hand-select a vintage ugly Christmas sweater from our warehouse and ship it straight to you. Every sweater is a genuine vintage piece from the '80s, '90s, or early 2000s—think sequins, embroidered Santas, puffy paint reindeer, and all the gloriously tacky holiday cheer you're looking for.
The photos you see here are just examples. Your sweater will be different—pulled from our constantly rotating warehouse stock of vintage finds.
Sizing Notes
These are vintage women's sweaters, so they tend to run small and boxy. We recommend ordering one size up from what you'd normally wear for the best fit.
Hundreds of Happy Customers
We don't accept returns or exchanges on mystery vintage items, but we've sold thousands of these with overwhelmingly positive reviews. Our team knows what makes a great ugly Christmas sweater, and we're confident you're going to love yours.
Want to pick your own? Check out our full collection of 5,000+ individually photographed vintage ugly Christmas sweaters and find the perfect one yourself.
I ordered 1 cardigan and 1 pullover sweater and can't be more pleased with the selections that were sent! Also, the fit is perfect. I would definitely recommend this seller.
Super cute sweater but really, really wrinkled. Hope storing it will help before I get a chance to wear it. Please choose a more reliable shipper next time. USPS didn't make it in time to wear it this year despite the latest arrival date given when ordered. Was supposed to come no later than 12/26 and it actually arrived 12/29. The sweater recipient actually flew home the day befoe.
I’ve bought a few mystery sweaters from here, this one is my favorite so far! No holes or rips, and after a quick wash its ready for Christmas season! Cant wait to wear it!
Cutest/ugliest Christmas sweater I’ve ever seen!! The mystery pack idea is so fun and the sweater did not disappoint!! Made for an excellent outfit. 100% worth the price and fun!
So cute and ready for New Years!! Thank you!!
I ordered a medium, and it was a hit! People loved it! The material is great, no stretching or wear/tear. All the decorative bits were fully attached and very cute. I took it to the dry cleaners after taking this picture, and it came out wonderfully.
The sweater arrived in the window as advertised. The sweater was missing a tiny bead; however, the overall quality of the sweater was in great condition. It was more of a “cute” than “ugly” sweater, but had the unique qualities of an unglued sweater…appliqués, beads, popping 3D image and all! Not a sweater I would purchase myself. I would recommend.
I ordered two sweaters--a vest and a cardigan. The orders came super promptly, however, I got two vests instead of a vest and a cardigan. I contacted the company and they quickily sent out another shipment with the cardigan for free. Great customer service and great truly unique Christmas sweaters!!
The sweater definitely serves its purpose! However, it arrived very wrinkled and missing a button on the left pocket.
This is such a fun idea! I was searching for a vintage Christmas sweater for a party and stumbled across this. The mystery element is so fun and I was so happy with the cardigan I got!
Sooo happy with my Christmas vest!!
These sweaters were great! Perfect for our holiday parties.
Ugly! Adorable! Obnoxious! Festive! Perfect!
Initially I had ordered two Xmas sweaters, & one of the items arrived ripped. Seller quickly responded to my concerns and quickly shipped me a replacement for the damaged item. Just received the replacement and this one even more beautiful! Because of how quickly the sellers responded to make my experience right, deff will purchase again and I even recommended them to a few friends !
Ordering a mystery sweater was tricky but I absolutely loved it!!!
I've ordered two different mystery sweaters and they both have been perfect!
Delivery was delayed because of our postal facility, not Etsy. I love my new sweater. It was very wrinkled, but I love the design. I hand washed it per instructions and it looks wonderful. Still drying flat as I write this.
The surprise sweater that arrived was definitely a vintage sweater, but I would not categorize it as an “ugly”Christmas sweater. It is definitely used (which is as expected) but it is pilling everywhere. It feels like it will be scratchy as well. So I’m a little disappointed. I will likely order a different ugly Christmas sweater from Amazon to wear to our Ugly Christmas Sweater party. I guess I’ll donate this one.
really cute random christmas cardigan and it arrived in the mail quick and looks great
Absolutely gorgeous! Fast shipping, extremely worth it, can’t wait to wear it!
Unfortunately one of the sweaters i purchase was ripped :( the sweater design was very cute but the sweater itself was ripped. Unfortunately I can’t use this sweater :(
I ordered this item last year and loved it, so I was pretty disappointed this year when my sweater arrived with this piece of tape stuck to the back that will not come off, no matter what I try. It's like it's fused to the sweater. So now I can't wear the sweater, because there's this super noticeable white tape on the back, and I've wasted money. I really like the sweater otherwise, but I'm really disappointed and upset that I can't wear it due to the tape.
Love the button down sweater I got. Such a fun way to add extra holiday cheer.
